12 Best Vanilla Cigars to Try in 2025
There’s something undeniably comforting about the aroma of vanilla, and when it meets a well-rolled cigar, the result is pure indulgence. Vanilla flavored cigars have carved out a loyal following thanks to their smooth, aromatic profile and crowd-pleasing sweetness. Whether you're into rich, dessert-like smokes or prefer a more traditional cigar with just a whisper of vanilla, there’s a blend out there that fits the vibe.
In this guide, we break down the best vanilla cigars worth trying in 2025. From mellow cigarillos to premium long-filler masterpieces, each pick brings its own take on this timeless flavor.
TL;DR
Vanilla cigars come in two styles: flavored (infused with vanilla oils and essences) and natural (featuring subtle vanilla notes from wrappers or cedar aging). Both styles offer smooth, creamy smokes, one bold and sweet, the other more subtle and refined. Here are 12 of the best cigars with vanilla notes to explore in 2025:
1. Lucky Flavors Vanilla
2. Lucky Flavors Vanilla Sky
3. Lucky Flavors Creme Brulee
4. Vanilla Flavored Cigarillos by Lucky Cigar
5. Tatiana Classic Vanilla
6. Acid Blue Blondie
7. CAO Bella Vanilla
8. Classico by Lucky Cigar
9. Habana Nights by Lucky Cigar
10. Oliva Connecticut Reserve
11. Cohiba Connecticut
12. Drew Estate Larutan Dirt
What Gives a Cigar Vanilla Notes?
Vanilla in a cigar doesn’t always come from a bottle, it depends on how the cigar is made and what it's made of. Some cigars are infused, meaning they’re intentionally flavored with vanilla oils, essences, or even soaked in sweet mixtures after being rolled. This gives them that unmistakable dessert-like taste from the very first puff. It's bold, it's obvious, and it's exactly what some smokers love.
But not all vanilla cigars are flavored. Sometimes, that soft vanilla hint just shows up on its own. This usually happens in cigars with a Connecticut Shade wrapper. These light-colored leaves naturally bring out creamy, nutty tones and sometimes, if you're paying attention, a little trace of vanilla. There’s also the magic of time. Cigars aged in cedar-lined rooms can take on sweet, woody notes that mellow out the tobacco and give it a warm, vanilla-like finish. No added flavors, just nature doing its thing.
So whether you’re into the obvious sweetness of a flavored stick or the quiet vanilla whisper of a naturally aged cigar, there’s something in that profile for every kind of smoker.
Criteria Breakdown: How We Selected the Best Vanilla Cigars
Not all vanilla cigars are created equal. Some taste like a bakery in the best way: smooth, creamy, a little toasty. Others? More like a melted candle. So we were picky.
Flavor authenticity was non-negotiable. We looked for vanilla that tastes real, not syrupy or fake. It had to feel like it belonged in the cigar, not slapped on as an afterthought.
Construction and burn mattered too. A great flavor can’t save a poorly rolled cigar. We wanted cigars that draw easily, burn evenly, and don’t fall apart halfway through.
Balance was the secret sauce. Vanilla should compliment the tobacco, not drown it out. A good vanilla cigar lets you enjoy both the sweet and the smoky in one smooth ride.
Versatility was also key. Whether you're lighting up with your morning coffee or winding down after dinner, these cigars needed to feel right at home.
And of course, price. We made sure there’s something here for every budget—whether you’re grabbing a quick flavored stick or reaching for a premium blend on a special night.
Our Top Picks of Vanilla Flavored Cigars
Love sweet, dessert-style cigars? These vanilla flavored cigars deliver rich aroma and creamy taste. For more smooth, sweet options, check out our list of the best sweet cigars to try.
1. Lucky Flavors Vanilla
This is the classic go-to for anyone craving a smooth and sweet vanilla cigar without overwhelming the palate. Lucky Flavors Vanilla delivers rich aroma and a creamy vanilla essence from the first puff to the last. With Dominican fillers and an Indonesian wrapper, it’s mellow but flavorful, perfect for daily relaxation or a light after-meal smoke. It’s one of the most affordable vanilla flavored cigars that still hits all the right notes of balance and smoothness, an easy pick for anyone looking for something light, flavorful, and approachable.
Strength: Mild to medium
Wrapper: Indonesian
Filler: Dominican
Binder: Dominican
Price: $4.00 per cigar
Rating:
Flavor Authenticity: 5/5
Construction & Burn: 5/5
Balance: 5/5
Versatility: 4.5/5
Affordability: 5/5
2. Lucky Flavors Vanilla Sky
Vanilla Sky takes the original formula and layers it with extra warmth. Expect toasted vanilla, caramel, and a hint of cream in each draw. The profile is slightly fuller, while still maintaining the mellow character of the Lucky Flavors line. This cigar blends Dominican fillers and an Indonesian wrapper for a smooth, slow burn. It’s a great option for smokers who enjoy sweet vanilla cigars with a bit more depth and dessert-like finish.
Strength: Mild to medium
Wrapper: Indonesian
Filler: Dominican
Binder: Dominican
Price: $4.00 per cigar
Rating:
Flavor Authenticity: 4.5/5
Construction & Burn: 5/5
Balance: 4.5/5
Versatility: 4.5/5
Affordability: 5/5
3. Lucky Flavors Creme Brulee
A dessert cigar through and through, Creme Brulee combines custard-like sweetness, vanilla cream, and a touch of caramelized sugar. It’s smooth and fragrant, using Dominican fillers and an Indonesian wrapper to keep things mellow but flavorful. Ideal for pairing with coffee or dessert drinks, this cigar is a standout among vanilla flavored cigars for those who love indulgent smokes with a rich aroma and creamy finish.
Strength: Mild to medium
Wrapper: Indonesian
Filler: Dominican
Binder: Dominican
Price: $4.00 per cigar
Rating:
Flavor Authenticity: 5/5
Construction & Burn: 5/5
Balance: 4.5/5
Versatility: 4/5
Affordability: 5/5
4. Vanilla Flavored Cigarillos by Lucky Cigar
Short, sweet, and satisfying, these Vanilla Cigarillos from Lucky Cigar are made for flavor on the go. Despite their smaller size, they pack a clean vanilla aroma and smooth draw, wrapped in an Indonesian leaf with Dominican fillers. Great for quick breaks or casual smokers, these vanilla cigars prove you don’t need size for satisfaction. Their consistency, affordability, and pleasant finish make them a top pick for everyday flavor.
Strength: Mild
Wrapper: Indonesian
Filler: Dominican
Binder: Dominican
Price: $1.80 per cigar (box of 25)
Rating:
Flavor Authenticity: 4.5/5
Construction & Burn: 4.5/5
Balance: 5/5
Versatility: 4.5/5
Affordability: 5/5
5. Tatiana Classic Vanilla
Tatiana Classic Vanilla is one of the most recognizable names in the world of vanilla flavored cigars. It features a silky Indonesian wrapper and Dominican fillers infused with high-quality vanilla flavoring. The smoke is creamy, aromatic, and balanced with a soft sweetness that never overwhelms. It’s an excellent starter cigar but also appreciated by seasoned smokers who enjoy a smooth, reliable draw. Perfect for pairing with coffee or an after-dinner drink, this is a fan favorite for good reason.
Source: tatianacigars.com
Strength: Medium
Wrapper: Indonesian Colorado Maduro
Filler: Dominican
Binder: Dominican
Price: From $4.50 per cigar
Rating:
Flavor Authenticity: 5/5
Construction & Burn: 4.5/5
Balance: 4.5/5
Versatility: 4.5/5
Affordability: 4.5/5
6. Acid Blue Blondie
Acid Blondie Blue by Drew Estate is often praised for its creamy, sweet profile with notes that remind smokers of vanilla, honey, and flowers, which makes it to the list of best vanilla cigars. It’s small in size but rich in character, using Nicaraguan filler and a light Connecticut wrapper. The unique infusion process gives it a signature taste that stands out. Ideal for casual smokers looking for something smooth, aromatic, and a little unconventional.
Source: jrcigars.com
Strength: Mild
Wrapper: Connecticut Shade
Filler: Nicaraguan
Binder: Nicaraguan
Price: From $5.90 per cigar
Rating:
Flavor Authenticity: 4.5/5
Construction & Burn: 4.5/5
Balance: 4.5/5
Versatility: 4/5
Affordability: 4/5
7. CAO Bella Vanilla
CAO Bella Vanilla is one of the premium vanilla flavored cigars made using authentic vanilla beans from Madagascar. The result is a mellow, creamy smoke with floral sweetness and a smooth finish. It uses a Cameroon wrapper over Dominican fillers, offering a more refined experience than most flavored cigars. This one’s perfect for special occasions or quiet nights when you want a bit of sweetness without sacrificing quality. A great pick for smokers who want elegance and flavor in one.
Strength: Medium
Wrapper: Cameroon
Filler: Dominican
Binder: Nicaraguan
Price: From $6.75 per cigar
Rating:
Flavor Authenticity: 5/5
Construction & Burn: 4.5/5
Balance: 5/5
Versatility: 4.5/5
Affordability: 3.5/5
Best Natural Cigars with Vanilla Notes
Prefer subtle notes over infused flavor? These natural cigars offer soft vanilla notes. Explore more in our naturally sweet cigars guide.
8. Classico by Lucky Cigar
The Classico is a mellow, easygoing cigar with creamy smoke and soft vanilla-like sweetness, thanks to its Connecticut Shade wrapper. It’s ideal for those who prefer a subtle profile rather than bold flavors. You’ll notice light notes of cedar, cream, and a whisper of vanilla in the finish. This cigar is a great option for morning or casual afternoon smokes. A solid choice among cigars with sublte vanilla notes that don’t rely on artificial flavoring.
Strength: Mild
Wrapper: Connecticut Shade
Filler: San Andres
Binder: Ometepe
Price: From $7.00 per cigar
Rating:
Flavor Authenticity: 5/5
Construction & Burn: 4/5
Balance: 4/5
Versatility: 4.5/5
Affordability: 5/5
9. Habana Nights by Lucky Cigar
Habana Nights brings together Nicaraguan filler and a Habano wrapper for a medium-bodied smoke with rich, earthy tones and faint vanilla undertones. It’s flavorful but balanced, making it a solid step up for those who’ve tried flavored cigars and want something more traditional. Smooth, aromatic, and well-made, it works beautifully in the evening or paired with coffee. One of the more complex options among cigars with vanilla notes.
Strength: Medium
Wrapper: Connecticut Shade
Filler: Nicaraguan
Binder: Honduras
Price: $13.00 per cigar
Rating:
Flavor Authenticity: 4.5/5
Construction & Burn: 4.5/5
Balance: 4.5/5
Versatility: 5/5
Affordability: 4/5
10. Oliva Connecticut Reserve
Oliva’s Connecticut Reserve is mild and creamy, perfect for smokers who enjoy mellow cigars with a soft finish. While not flavored, it delivers faint vanilla, nuts, and toast from its aged Nicaraguan tobacco and Connecticut wrapper. It’s refined, smooth, and incredibly easy to smoke. A top pick for fans of cigars with vanilla notes that feel natural rather than infused.
Strength: Mild
Wrapper: Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade
Filler: Nicaraguan
Binder: Nicaraguan
Price: From $6.15 per cigar
Rating:
Flavor Authenticity: 4.5/5
Construction & Burn: 5/5
Balance: 4.5/5
Versatility: 4.5/5
Affordability: 5/5
11. Cohiba Connecticut
Smooth, elegant, and subtly sweet, Cohiba Connecticut is everything you’d expect from a premium cigar. It features creamy, light flavors with a refined vanilla backdrop, thanks to its Connecticut Shade wrapper and a complex filler blend. It’s ideal for relaxed evenings or special occasions. While priced higher, it earns its place among the best natural cigars with vanilla notes for its craftsmanship and flavor harmony.
Strength: Mild
Wrapper: Ecuadorian Connecticut Shade
Filler: Dominican, Nicaraguan, Brazilian
Binder: Mexican San Andrés
Price: From $23.40 per cigar
Rating:
Flavor Authenticity: 5/5
Construction & Burn: 5/5
Balance: 5/5
Versatility: 4.5/5
Affordability: 3/5
12. Larutan Dirt
Larutan Dirt is a medium-bodied, wildly unique cigar crafted with a blend of tobaccos from 12 countries—including Brazil, Nicaragua, and Turkey—wrapped in a dark Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro. Every puff is layered with mocha, coffee, oak, black pepper, and a soft trace of vanilla. The flavor is bold but smooth, making it a standout for smokers who want complexity with a touch of sweetness. It’s one of the most intriguing cigars with vanilla notes for those craving something different and full of character.
Source: tchcigars.com
Strength: Medium
Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro
Filler: Nicaraguan
Binder: Nicaraguan
Price: Approximately $6.50 per cigar (box of 24)
Rating:
Flavor Authenticity: 4.5/5
Construction & Burn: 4.5/5
Balance: 4.5/5
Versatility: 4/5
Affordability: 4/5
Perfect Pairings: What to Sip and Snack On with Vanilla Cigars
A good vanilla cigar already offers a creamy, aromatic smoke, but pairing it with the right drink or dessert can take things to the next level. Whether you're after comfort, contrast, or a touch of indulgence, these pairings bring out the best in flavored cigars and those with natural vanilla notes.
Drinks That Pair Well:
- Coffee with cream or vanilla latte: Smooth, sweet, and familiar, perfect for enhancing the creamy qualities of the cigar.
- Aged rum or vanilla-infused bourbon: These add warmth and richness, deepening the natural sweetness and spice in the tobacco.
- Chai latte or spiced tea: Ideal for cooler weather or a cozy smoke session, the gentle spices complement vanilla’s soft profile.
- Sweet red wine or port: A luxurious pairing that enhances both the body and finish of the cigar.
- Cream soda or root beer: These nostalgic, sweet beverages highlight the vanilla flavor in a fun, casual way.
Desserts and Foods to Enjoy:
- Crème brûlée or vanilla custard: These creamy desserts echo the smooth sweetness of the cigar.
- Vanilla bean ice cream: Cold and clean, this pairing enhances the cigar’s dessert-like qualities.
- Shortbread cookies or almond biscotti: Buttery and crisp, these add texture and contrast without overpowering the smoke.
- Banana bread or vanilla pound cake: Dense and sweet, these comfort foods align beautifully with the cigar’s warm flavors.
- Dark chocolate with sea salt: A bold pairing that balances sweetness with a hint of bitterness and complexity.
When pairing food or drink with vanilla cigars, think about harmony—mild flavors that complement, not compete. Creamy textures, warm spices, and gentle sweetness tend to bring out the cigar’s best.
Final Thoughts
The best vanilla cigars offer more than just flavor—they create a full sensory experience that’s warm, smooth, and memorable. Whether you lean toward infused sticks bursting with dessert-like sweetness or prefer the understated elegance of cigars with natural vanilla notes, there’s no shortage of great options to explore.
With picks for every budget, taste preference, and occasion, this list brings together some of the most enjoyable cigars on the market today. If you're new to flavored cigars and curious about more approachable options beyond vanilla, don’t miss our guide to the best flavored cigars for beginners. Light one up, pair it with your favorite drink or dessert, and enjoy a smoke that’s as relaxing as it is flavorful.
