Top 17 Happy New Year Cigar Picks to Celebrate 2025
New Year’s Eve is all about celebrating the past, toasting to the future, and savoring the moment. And what better way to do that than with a happy New Year cigar? Whether you’re popping champagne, sipping your favorite cocktail, or enjoying a quiet moment with loved ones, the right cigar adds that perfect touch of luxury and indulgence to the night.
In this blog, we’ve rounded up 17 incredible cigars to help you welcome 2025 in style. From smooth, beginner-friendly smokes to bold, complex blends for seasoned enthusiasts, there’s a perfect cigar here for every kind of celebration. So, grab your favorite drink, light up, and let’s make this New Year’s Eve one to remember!
Table of Content
1 - Lucky Flavors Creme Brulee
2 - Mellow Mellow Reserve
3 - Lucky Flavors Cognac
4 - Habana Nights
5 - Lucky Flavors Vanilla
6 - Cafeina Ice Medium Roast
7 - Lucky Flavors Sex on the Beach
8 - Especial Habano by Lucky Cigar
9 - Lucky Flavors Pina Colada
10 - Rustyko by Lucky Cigar
11 - Casa Magna Colorado
12 - Oliva Serie G
13 - La Aroma de Cuba Noblesse
14 - Romeo Y Julieta 1875
15 - AVO Syncro Caribe
16 - CLE 25th Anniversary
17 - Davidoff Winston Churchill Late Hour
Pairing Cigars with New Year's Drinks
Final Thoughts
The Best Cigars for New Year's Eve
1 - Lucky Flavors Creme Brulee
If you're looking for a happy New Year cigar to indulge your sweet tooth, the Lucky Flavors Creme Brulee cigar is a fantastic choice. Infused with creamy, caramelized sugar notes, it mimics the classic dessert while offering a smooth, mild smoking experience. Its balanced flavor profile makes it an excellent option for dessert pairings, like a glass of champagne or even a rich espresso. This cigar's sweet and inviting aroma sets a celebratory tone, perfect for sharing with guests or savoring during a reflective moment as the clock strikes midnight. The Creme Brulee cigar is approachable for beginners yet satisfying for seasoned smokers, making it a crowd-pleaser at any New Year's gathering.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Creamy, sweet, and dessert-like.
Aroma: Mild with caramelized sugar notes.
Construction: Smooth draw, even burn.
Wrapper Quality: Elegant Indonesian wrapper.
Body: Mild to medium.
Pros
- The smooth flavor profile pairs beautifully with desserts or champagne.
- Its mild body makes it perfect for beginners or casual smokers.
Cons
- Could be too mild for those seeking a bold, complex cigar.
Price:
2 - Mellow Mellow Reserve
Features:
Flavor Profile: Rich, creamy with botanical notes.
Aroma: Aromatic and soothing.
Construction: Even burn, smooth draw.
Wrapper Quality: Luxurious Esteli wrapper.
Body: Mild to medium.
Pros
- Unique infusion makes it stand out among flavored cigars.
- High-quality tobacco ensures a smooth, enjoyable New Year cigar experience.
Cons
- Not ideal for those who prefer traditional cigar flavors.
Price:
3 - Lucky Flavors Cognac 
The Lucky Flavors Cognac cigar brings a touch of sophistication to your New Year's celebration. Infused with warm, rich cognac notes, this mild to medium-bodied cigar is perfect for pairing with your favorite spirits, especially a glass of—you guessed it—cognac or bourbon. Its luxurious flavor and aromatic profile make it an excellent choice for a midnight toast. The subtle sweetness and smooth finish create a celebratory vibe, whether you're enjoying it with friends or during a moment of solitude. Elevate your cigar experience with this refined and celebratory smoke—truly one of the best cigars for New Year's Eve.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Smooth with refined cognac hints.
Aroma: Pleasant and elegant.
Construction: Reliable draw, even burn.
Wrapper Quality: Silky Indonesian wrapper.
Body: Mild to medium.
Pros
- Refined cognac notes complement any toast, making it an ideal cigar for New Year parties.
- Suitable for both novice and experienced smokers.
Cons
- Might lack complexity for aficionados seeking a bold experience.
Price:
4 - Habana Nights
Celebrate New Year's Eve with a tropical twist by lighting up the Habana Nights cigar. Offering medium-bodied richness with hints of spice and earthiness, this cigar captures the lively spirit of Havana. Its bold yet smooth flavor profile makes it a versatile option for pairing with everything from rum cocktails to Cuban-style coffee. This is the perfect cigar for New Year parties where you want something lively and bold. It's a great choice for seasoned smokers who want something bold but not overpowering. Whether you're dancing the night away or enjoying a laid-back celebration, this cigar complements the excitement and warmth of the occasion.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Creamy, nutty, medium body.
Aroma: Warm with toasted notes.
Construction: Long-lasting, smooth draw.
Wrapper Quality: Premium Connecticut shade.
Body: Medium.
Pros
- The creamy profile pairs well with whiskey or espresso.
- Excellent construction ensures a slow, enjoyable New Year cigar experience.
Cons
- Might feel a bit strong for beginners.
Price:
5 - Lucky Flavors Vanilla
The Lucky Flavors Vanilla cigar offers a light and creamy smoking experience that's as comforting as it is festive. Infused with the smooth essence of vanilla, this mild cigar is ideal for those who enjoy sweeter, aromatic smokes. It's perfect for beginners or anyone who prefers a gentler flavor profile. The soothing vanilla notes pair wonderfully with champagne or a light dessert wine, making this happy New Year cigar a delightful addition to your midnight toast. Its approachable flavor and pleasant aroma also make it a great choice for sharing with guests, ensuring everyone can enjoy the experience. Light up this cigar for a sweet start to the new year.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Mild with vanilla sweetness.
Aroma: Subtle and festive.
Construction: Beginner-friendly, even burn.
Wrapper Quality: Smooth Indonesian wrapper.
Body: Mild to medium.
Pros
- The vanilla flavor is approachable and enjoyable for all, making it an ideal cigar for New Year gatherings.
- Its mild nature makes it great for sharing with friends.
Cons
- Lacks the complexity that seasoned smokers may desire.
Price:
6 - Cafeina Ice Medium Roast
Coffee lovers, rejoice! The Caféina Ice Medium Roast cigar is your go-to cigar for New Year celebrations. With notes of roasted coffee and a refreshing touch of coolness, this cigar is both invigorating and satisfying. Its mild to medium-bodied profile strikes the perfect balance between richness and smoothness. Pair it with an espresso martini or a hot coffee to keep the energy going as you welcome the new year. The Cafeina Ice is ideal for a post-dinner smoke or as a pick-me-up before the midnight countdown. Its unique flavor profile makes it a conversation starter, perfect for sharing with fellow cigar enthusiasts at your New Year's gathering.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Creamy cappuccino with a touch of mint—delightfully unique and smooth.
Aroma: Rich coffee notes with a refreshing hint of cream.
Construction: Expertly crafted for a consistent draw and burn.
Wrapper Quality: Sleek Connecticut shade leaf from Ecuador.
Body: Mild to medium.
Pros
- The coffee-mint blend is unique and offers a refreshing twist on traditional cigars.
- Its mild body makes it approachable for beginners and enjoyable for seasoned smokers.
Cons
- The minty flavor might be off-putting to smokers who prefer classic cigar profiles.
Price:
7 - Lucky Flavors Sex on the Beach
If you're in the mood for something playful and tropical this New Year's Eve, the Lucky Flavors Sex on the Beach cigar is the way to go. Inspired by the iconic cocktail, this mild to medium-bodied cigar bursts with fruity flavors like peach and orange, balanced by smooth tobacco notes. Its vibrant, festive profile makes it the perfect cigar for New Year parties where fun and flavor take center stage. Pair it with a cocktail or enjoy it during the countdown for a flavorful start to the year. Its unique taste and approachable strength also make it a great conversation starter for parties.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Fruity and smooth, capturing the fun essence of a cocktail.
Aroma: Light and tropical, perfect for celebrations.
Construction: Reliable draw with an even burn throughout.
Wrapper Quality: Polished Indonesian wrapper adds a refined touch.
Body: Mild to medium.
Pros
- Its fruity flavor captures the celebratory spirit of a tropical cocktail, making it a perfect cigar for New Year parties.
- Mild body and smooth construction make it a great choice for casual or first-time smokers.
Cons
- Lacks depth and complexity, which may not appeal to more experienced cigar enthusiasts.
Price:
8 - Especial Habano by Lucky Cigar
For a more traditional smoking experience, the Especial Habano delivers rich, medium to full-bodied complexity. Wrapped in a premium Habano leaf, it offers notes of spice, cedar, and subtle sweetness, perfect for seasoned smokers. This classic cigar is ideal for creating a moment of reflection amidst the celebration. Pair it with a glass of whiskey or cognac to amplify its bold flavors. Whether you're toasting with friends or savoring it solo, it's undoubtedly one of the best cigars for New Year's Eve for seasoned smokers seeking a traditional touch.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Rich, earthy, and complex with spicy undertones.
Aroma: Robust and deep, with a satisfying punch.
Construction: Perfectly box-pressed for an effortless draw.
Wrapper Quality: Premium Condega wrapper elevates the experience.
Body: Mild to medium.
Pros
- Offers a bold, complex flavor profile that’s perfect for experienced smokers looking for depth.
- The box-pressed construction ensures a steady, smooth draw throughout the smoke.
Cons
- The strength and richness may overwhelm beginners or those who prefer lighter cigars.
Price:
9 - Lucky Flavors Pina Colada
Bring a tropical vibe to your New Year's Eve with the Lucky Flavors Pina Colada cigar. Infused with the creamy sweetness of coconut and pineapple, this mild cigar offers a dessert-like new year cigar experience that's refreshing and indulgent. It's perfect for beach-themed parties or when you're craving a touch of the tropics in winter. Pair it with a Pina Colada cocktail or a light dessert wine for a harmonious match. Its sweet aroma and mild strength make it a great choice for both beginners and seasoned smokers.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Creamy and tropical with a sweet finish.
Aroma: Sweet and light, reminiscent of a beach vacation.
Construction: Consistent burn with a smooth draw.
Wrapper Quality: Sleek Indonesian wrapper for a polished look.
Body: Mild to medium.
Pros
- The tropical and creamy flavor is festive and enjoyable, making it a great celebratory choice.
- Its mild profile ensures it’s accessible for both new and experienced smokers.
Cons
- Smokers seeking a bold or complex flavor may find it too simple.
Price:
10 - Rustyko by Lucky Cigar
The Rustyko cigar is a bold, medium-bodied option for those who love deep, complex flavors. Featuring notes of leather, cocoa, and pepper, this cigar provides a satisfying, long-lasting smoke. If you're planning a sophisticated New Year's celebration, Rustyko fits right in. Its robust flavor pairs beautifully with a glass of aged bourbon or a rich red wine. This happy New Year cigar commands attention and is a top choice for closing out the year in style.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Sweet berries and fruit with a toasty finish.
Aroma: Fruity and tropical, with warm, inviting notes.
Construction: Precision-made for a smooth, even burn.
Wrapper Quality: Premium Esteli wrapper adds richness.
Body: Medium.
Pros
- The fruity and toasty flavor profile transports you to a tropical island, making it an ideal celebratory smoke.
- Medium-bodied construction strikes a balance, appealing to a wide range of smokers.
Cons
- Smokers who prefer traditional or non-fruity flavors might not find this cigar as appealing.
Price:
11 - Casa Magna Colorado
Credit: neptunecigar.com
The Casa Magna Colorado is a full-bodied gem that brings elegance and boldness to your celebration. Wrapped in a gorgeous Nicaraguan wrapper, it delivers rich notes of coffee, cedar, and a hint of sweetness for a refined experience. This happy New Year cigar is ideal for pairing with cognac or a dark stout, making it a luxurious choice to toast the year's end. Its award-winning reputation ensures a top-tier experience, perfect for aficionados looking to make New Year's Eve unforgettable.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Rich, earthy, and nutty with hints of cocoa and spice.
Aroma: Warm and inviting, with a toasty and slightly sweet finish.
Construction: Flawlessly rolled for a steady burn and consistent draw.
Wrapper Quality: Smooth Nicaraguan wrapper.
Body: Full.
Pros
- The bold flavor profile makes it perfect for pairing with a celebratory whiskey or scotch.
- Excellent construction ensures an even burn and an enjoyable smoking experience.
Cons
- The full-bodied strength may be too intense for novice smokers.
Price:
12 - Oliva Serie G
Credit: neptunecigar.com
The Oliva Serie G is a mild classic featuring an African Cameroon wrapper. Its well-balanced flavor profile includes wood, coffee, and subtle spice, creating an approachable yet refined smoke that's perfect for any occasion. Whether you're enjoying a quiet evening or a lively celebration, the Oliva Serie G is one of the best cigars for New Year's Eve. Pair it with a glass of champagne or dark rum for a delightful new year cigar experience. Its versatility makes it a favorite among cigars to celebrate the New Year, offering a smooth and satisfying way to toast to the future.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Toasty and creamy with subtle hints of cedar and spice.
Aroma: Mild yet pleasant, with a touch of woodiness.
Construction: Expertly rolled, ensuring a consistent and smooth draw.
Wrapper Quality: Cameroon wrapper adds a rich depth of flavor.
Body: Mild.
Pros
- The balanced flavor profile makes it a great choice for both beginners and seasoned smokers.
- Compact and versatile, it’s an ideal cigar to enjoy during a festive evening, adding to your New Year cigar experience.
Cons
- Lacks the complexity that some aficionados might seek in a celebratory cigar.
Price:
13 - La Aroma de Cuba Noblesse
Credit: neptunecigar.com
La Aroma de Cuba Noblesse is the epitome of elegance, perfect for a luxurious New Year's celebration. This full-bodied cigar features a flawless Ecuadorian Habano wrapper and a blend of aged Nicaraguan tobaccos, delivering rich notes of cedar, spice, and a touch of natural sweetness. Its refined flavor profile and silky smooth draw make it ideal for pairing with a glass of champagne or fine cognac. Light it up during the midnight toast for a memorable happy New Year cigar moment that oozes sophistication.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Rich and complex, with notes of cocoa, cedar, and caramel.
Aroma: Elegant and inviting, with a sweet and spicy finish.
Construction: Meticulously crafted for an effortless draw and even burn.
Wrapper Quality: Silky Ecuadorian Habano Rosado wrapper enhances the premium feel.
Body: Full.
Pros
- The luxurious flavor profile makes it one of the best cigars to celebrate the New Year.
- Impeccable construction ensures a flawless smoking experience.
Cons
- The premium pricing may not be ideal for casual smokers.
Price:
14 - Romeo Y Julieta 1875
Credit: neptunecigar.com
The Romeo y Julieta 1875 is a timeless classic, offering a balanced mild smoke with flavors of cedar, roasted nuts and a hint of cinnamon. Its impeccable construction ensures a smooth, consistent burn, making it a dependable choice. This versatile cigar fits any celebration, from casual gatherings to elegant parties. Pair it with sparkling wine for a perfectly harmonious experience. It's a great cigar for New Year festivities, especially for those who love traditional yet approachable flavors.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Mellow and smooth with notes of nuts, cedar, and light spice.
Aroma: Mild and pleasing, perfect for social settings.
Construction: Reliable and consistent, with an easy draw and steady burn.
Wrapper Quality: Beautiful Java TBN wrapper.
Body: Mild.
Pros
- The approachable flavor profile makes it a versatile choice for smokers of all experience levels.
- Classic and well-crafted, it’s a crowd-pleaser for festive gatherings.
Cons
- Seasoned smokers may find it too mild for their preferences.
Price:
15 - AVO Syncro Caribe
Credit: neptunecigar.com
Bring a touch of the Caribbean to your New Year's Eve with the AVO Syncro Caribe. This medium-bodied cigar offers a vibrant blend of creamy coffee, citrus, and tropical spice, wrapped in a luscious Dominican leaf. Its lively flavor profile pairs wonderfully with rum-based cocktails, making it a standout for tropical-themed celebrations. Whether you're hosting a party or enjoying a solo new year cigar experience, the Syncro Caribe adds an adventurous vibe to your night.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Creamy and balanced with hints of citrus, cedar, and spice.
Aroma: Bright and tropical, reminiscent of the Caribbean.
Construction: Expertly crafted for a steady draw and even burn.
Wrapper Quality: Dominican wrapper.
Body: Medium.
Pros
- The vibrant flavor profile is perfect for pairing with rum or tropical cocktails.
- Its medium body makes it enjoyable for both casual and seasoned smokers.
Cons
- Smokers seeking bold or complex flavors may find it a bit light.
Price:
16 - CLE 25th Anniversary
Credit: neptunecigar.com
The CLE 25th Anniversary is a bold, medium-bodied cigar that celebrates craftsmanship. With its Honduran wrapper and expertly aged tobaccos, it delivers complex notes of earth, espresso, and leather. This celebratory cigar is a natural fit for marking milestones like the new year. Its robust flavors pair perfectly with bourbon or a rich stout, making it one of the best cigars for New Year's Eve for aficionados who love intensity and depth.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Rich and earthy with notes of coffee and leather.
Aroma: Deep and luxurious with a warm, toasty essence.
Construction: Perfectly rolled for an even burn and smooth draw.
Wrapper Quality: Honduran wrapper with an impeccable finish.
Body: Medium.
Pros
- The robust flavor makes it an ideal pairing with bourbon or dark rum.
- High-quality construction ensures a consistent smoking experience.
Cons
- Its bold nature may not appeal to newer smokers.
Price:
17 - Davidoff Winston Churchill Late Hour
Credit: neptunecigar.com
The Davidoff Winston Churchill Late Hour is a luxurious, full-bodied cigar aged in Scotch whisky barrels. Its unique profile offers notes of pepper, coffee, and leather, with a hint of dried fruit and spice, perfect for a refined new year cigar experience. This cigar embodies sophistication, making it ideal for an elegant New Year's celebration. Pair it with a fine single malt whisky to complement its complex flavors. Light it up during a reflective moment or as part of a midnight toast—it's a cigar to celebrate the New Year in style.
Features:
Flavor Profile: Deep and complex with notes of pepper, coffee and dried fruit.
Aroma: Rich and luxurious, with hints of leather and spice.
Construction: Impeccably crafted for a smooth, effortless draw.
Wrapper Quality: Ecuadorian Habano wrapper.
Body: Full.
Pros
- The complex flavor profile makes it a perfect companion to fine spirits like cognac or aged whiskey.
- Exquisite craftsmanship ensures an unparalleled smoking experience.
Cons
- Its premium price may not suit casual occasions.
Price:
Pairing Cigars with New Year's Drinks
Pairing the right cigar with your New Year’s drink is the perfect way to elevate your celebration. Whether you’re sipping bubbly champagne or indulging in a festive cocktail, the right combination creates a truly memorable new year cigar experience.
Champagne is synonymous with celebration, making it a natural partner for a happy New Year cigar. The effervescence of champagne, with its bright and crisp flavors, pairs beautifully with cigars that offer smooth, creamy, or nutty notes. The bubbles refresh your palate, cutting through the richness of the cigar, creating a seamless balance between smoke and sip. It’s the ultimate pairing for a midnight toast, combining luxury and celebration in every puff and sip.
Cocktails offer endless possibilities for pairing, depending on the style of drink. The key is to match the intensity of the cigar to the drink for a well-rounded experience. Spirit-forward drinks like old fashioneds or negronis complement cigars with bold, earthy flavors, bringing out the complexity in both. On the other hand, fruity, tropical cocktails like mojitos or piña coladas harmonize with cigars that carry sweet or aromatic notes, enhancing the festive vibe. Check out our list of the best sweet cigars here.
Final Thoughts
As you prepare to welcome 2025, there’s no better way to celebrate than with the perfect cigar in hand. A great happy New Year cigar isn’t just about the smoke—it’s about creating a memorable experience that complements the joy, reflection, and excitement of the evening. Whether you prefer something bold and complex or smooth and sweet, the right cigar can elevate your celebration and make every moment special.
So, grab your favorite drink, light up a premium pick from our list, and savor the magic of the new year. Here’s to great cigars, unforgettable moments, and a fresh start. Happy New Year and happy smoking!
